
|
Please include
Israel's captive soldiers in your tefillot: Zecharia Shlomo ben
Miriam Baumel, Tzvi ben Penina Feldman, Yekutiel Yehuda Nachman ben Sarah
Katz, Ron ben Batya Arad, Guy ben Rina Chever.
Wednesday, 8 Shevat 5772 – February 1, 2012
The Torah in Parashat Beshalach describes
Benei Yisrael’s reaction upon seeing the Egyptian army pursuing them as they encamped near the
sea:
The Israelites cried out to the Lord. They said to
Moshe: “Is it because there are no graves in Egypt that you have taken us to
perish in the wilderness?
What is this that you did to us by taking us out of
Egypt?
Is this not what we told you in Egypt – ‘Leave us alone and
let us serve Egypt’?
For it is better to serve Egypt than to perish in
the wilderness!(14:10-12)
The obvious question arises as to how to reconcile the two different reactions
described in these verses.
Is it conceivable that
Benei Yisrael
“cried out to the Lord” in prayer and then immediately turned to Moshe to accuse
him of leading them out of Egypt to die in the desert?
Could it be that they reacted with both heartfelt prayer and angry rejection of
Moshe?
This question is likely what prompted
Chazal, as cited by the Ramban, to explain that three different
groups formed during those anxiety-ridden moments on the seashore.
One group prayed, whereas the others angrily challenged Moshe.
When the Torah describes both prayer and virulent condemnation of Moshe, it
refers to two different groups among Benei
Yisrael.
The Ramban also notes Targum Onkelos’ solution, translating the word “va-yitz’aku” (“they cried out”)
as “u-ze’iku,” which,
according to the Ramban, refers not to prayer, but to protest and complaint.
Another approach, as noted by the Ramban, is that
the Torah speaks of two different stages. When
Benei Yisrael first saw the
Egyptian army pursuing them, they turned to the Almighty in sincere, heartfelt
prayer.
But then, as the
Mekhilta comments, “once they placed yeast in the dough, they came to Moshe
and said, ‘Is this not what we told you…’” The Ramban
explains that the term “se’or she-be’isa” (“the yeast in the
dough”) refers to the
yetzer ha-ra.
In this instance, it refers to the challenge of unanswered prayer.
The people prayed, but their prayer did not appear to yield the desired result.
Pharaoh and his men continued approaching, and drew nearer and nearer.
Benei Yisrael concluded that their prayer was futile, and so they
despaired.
They lost faith in the entire enterprise of
Yetzi’at Mitzrayim, and angrily scoffed at
Moshe.
This final answer of the Ramban may add insight to
the verse in Tehillim (106:7) that speaks of Benei
Yisrael
“betraying” on the shores of the Sea of Reeds – “va-yamru
al yam be-Yam Suf.” Rashi, in his
commentary to Tehillim, explains this verse based on a Midrashic tradition that
after crossing the sea, Benei Yisrael still feared that the Egyptians would reach them on the shore,
still refusing to believe that God had delivered then.
The Radak and Ibn Ezra, however, accept the more intuitive reading, that the
Psalmist refers here to
Benei Yisrael’s angry and cynical
outburst against Moshe as they found themselves trapped against the sea.
According to the Ramban, this “betrayal” was the rejection of faith at a time
when the people felt that their faith had failed them.
Expecting God to provide an immediate solution to their predicament,
Benei Yisrael experienced a
crisis of faith when the solution didn’t come. And this
despair, borne out of impatience, is deemed “betrayal” (“va-yamru”).
This “betrayal” is reminiscent of the incident of
Mei
Meriva, when Moshe called the people “morim” (“betrayers” – Bamidbar 20:10) for their angry reaction to
a water crisis: “Why have you brought the congregation of the Lord to this
desert to die there…” (Bamidbar 20:4). Like at the
shores of the Yam Suf,
the people confronted a crisis situation and rushed to the conclusion that
Yetzi’at Mitzrayim was a
mistake, rather than humbly and patiently waiting to see how God would rescue
them.
If we harbor expectations that God must grant all our
wishes, acquiesce to all our demands, and grant all our requests, precisely the
way we want Him to, then we commit an act of “betrayal.”
Faith means accepting God’s authority and obeying His will regardless of what He
throws our way, without expecting Him to accommodate our particular wishes
according to our preferred schedule. We do not reject
our mission and stature when unforeseen crises surface and God does not appear
to answer our payers.
Instead, we heed God’s command to Moshe – “Speak to
the Israelites that they should journey onward” (14:15), continuing to progress
and move forward in fulfilling our duties as God’s special nation.
Rav David Silverberg |
|
THE
COMPLETE SALT ARCHIVES CAN BE FOUND AT: www.vbm-torah.org/salt-archives.html (c) 2012 Israel Koschitzky Virtual Beit Midrash, Yeshivat Har Etzion.
|
|
|
Come study in the VIRTUAL BEIT
MIDRASH - Torah by email